A shortlist you can use to compare placements
Copy a row for each candidate. Replace the example with an exact page or discussion and the buyer question it answers. If the page would be of little use without an AI citation, move on.
Blank entry: [page and date checked]; [buyer and question]; [market and language]; [who checks it and how]; [evidence URL or no citation observed]; [what the reader can do with it].
| Candidate | Audience | Market | Editorial check | Source of the observation | Value for the reader |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Industry directory | Buyers building a shortlist | Country and category the directory actually covers | Read inclusion and review rules. Check whether paid visibility is labeled separately. | Category page, published rules and one current example entry | Compare providers by service, coverage or eligibility. |
| Trade publication | Practitioners comparing methods or suppliers | Language and region of the publication | Check the byline, sourcing, affiliate or sponsor labels and how corrections are handled. | Relevant article, contributor policy or attributed editor reply | Use a comparison, test method or checklist to make a decision. |
| Community discussion | People troubleshooting a specific problem | Language and region of the thread, if relevant | Read the rules. Check who wrote the comment and whether any relationship is disclosed. | Exact thread, its rules and the question readers actually asked | Get a practical answer, including when the advice does not apply. |
| Company post on LinkedIn or Medium | People who can use a method your team can explain | Language and market covered by the evidence | Named company author, evidence and limits. The company controls the post. | Draft plus the public source material it summarizes | Reuse a checklist or inspect the data behind an observation. |
For how external sources fit alongside your site and measurement, start with our introduction to GEO.
What two archived citation lists tell you
The AI Source Index capture dated 9 November 2026 records URLs for the English question “Alternatives to Peloton for home cycling.” In that capture, Google AI Mode and Gemini both list the same Cycling Weekly buying guide. Gemini also lists an r/cycling thread about Peloton alternatives; the AI Mode entry does not list that thread.
On 16 November, the Cycling Weekly page showed a test method, comparisons by use case and an affiliate disclosure; it listed 29 September 2026 as its update date. The original Reddit post had been deleted, but comments remained, including a distinction between recreating a spin class and riding your own bike on an indoor trainer. The guide helps compare options. The comments help uncover a question to ask before comparing them.
The public archive preserves source URL lists, not the full answer text. It cannot show which passage a model used, why it selected a link or whether it endorsed a brand. The page checks describe what was visible on 16 November. This is one English question in one capture, with no basis for extrapolating to Poland, Ukraine or another category.
For your own market, use the buyer question template and save full answers alongside the exact URLs.
AI Source Index: 9 November 2026 source URL archive · Cycling Weekly: Exercise bike comparison and test method · Reddit, r/cycling: Discussion of Peloton alternatives
An editorial pitch that gives the reader something useful
Draft subject: “A checklist for comparing two AI citation reports”. Message: “I’m writing from BeeCited, a GEO agency. In your article on [specific topic], readers can see which sources were listed, but may have trouble comparing two reports. We can send a one-page checklist covering question, language, search mode and exact URLs, with a worked example and its limits. It lets readers see when two reports are comparable. You are free to verify, edit or decline it.”
Replace the brackets with something you read. Send the usable material and its provenance. If you cannot share the underlying records, offer a clearly marked demonstration or choose another angle. Ask who controls the headline and claims, and how sponsorship, affiliate links and corrections are handled.
Record who wrote, selected and paid for each placement. A founder’s guest article can be edited by a publication and still represent the founder. Label paid coverage as paid. Google Search Central’s spam policies, updated 28 August 2026, call for qualifying paid links with sponsored or nofollow attributes. That rule concerns Google Search; it does not assess editorial independence or promise a citation.
Google: Spam policies for Google web search
How to contribute on Reddit and LinkedIn
Reddit draft, for a thread asking why two citation reports disagree: “I work at BeeCited, a GEO agency. Before comparing the counts, check whether both reports ran the same question, in the same language and mode. Then compare the cited URLs, not just domains. If one report saved only the source list, use it to compare links; you cannot use it to compare what the answers said.” The reply works without a link or a sales pitch.
Reddit’s spam guidance, updated 30 October 2026, prohibits repeated or unsolicited mass engagement and points users to community rules. Read those rules first. Disclosing your affiliation does not make an otherwise prohibited post acceptable.
LinkedIn draft for the BeeCited company page: lead with “Two AI surfaces can show different source lists for the same buyer question.” Show the question, date, source archive and exact URLs for the Cycling Weekly guide and Reddit thread. Say which surface listed each and what the source list leaves unknown. End with a blank row readers can copy for their own question. This is a company-authored explanation of public data, not an independent review of BeeCited.
Reddit: Spam policy · AI Source Index: 9 November 2026 source URL archive · Cycling Weekly: Exercise bike comparison and test method · Reddit, r/cycling: Discussion of Peloton alternatives
Check the placement and the AI answer separately
Google Search Central’s guide to generative features, updated 10 July 2026, advises against pursuing inauthentic mentions. The page selection criteria above are for outreach to real readers. They do not describe a ranking formula.
- At placement: save the public URL, date, market, relationship and exact passage. Check who can read the page, whether the company is described accurately and whether any payment or affiliation is visible.
- In your answer sample: save the question, platform, search mode, language, market, date, full answer and linked URL. Record separately whether the brand is named and whether this particular page appears as a source. Open the page and check the claim.
- At review: compare repeated runs under the same conditions. Keep referral visits and accepted inquiries separate. Log other changes that may matter and treat a citation that appeared later as an observation, not proof of impact.
Google: Optimizing for generative AI features
Questions before committing outreach time
Should I pay for a directory listing that appeared in an AI answer?
Check what payment buys: a profile, a sponsored position or access to a relevant audience. Read the category page and sample entries. Approve the listing only if it is useful on those terms. A citation of a different listing on the same directory does not transfer to yours.
Can a mention without a link still be useful?
Yes. Readers can learn what a company does from a named reference, even if they cannot click through. Log it as an external mention. Count it as an AI brand mention only if an observed answer names the company, and as a cited page only if that answer links to the page.
What if the test returns no useful citations?
Start with your buyers’ public questions, relevant association resources and trade coverage. Record that you found no applicable citations in the current sample. A good source need not appear in the sample to be worth contacting. Repeat the check later under the same conditions.
Pick one buyer question and one useful contribution
Choose a question that matters before a purchase. Shortlist the pages that help someone answer it, then make one contribution you can substantiate. If the best option is a modest directory correction or a clear reply in a community, start there.
Bring your question and shortlist to our GEO service if you want help checking sources and planning outreach.
Sources & further reading
BeeCited provides GEO services. Sources were checked on 16 November 2026. The citation example uses public third-party records; the pitch and posts are unpublished templates. AI assisted the editorial, factual and language checks.
- AI Source Index: 9 November 2026 source URL archive —
- Cycling Weekly: Exercise bike comparison and test method —
- Reddit, r/cycling: Discussion of Peloton alternatives —
- Google: Spam policies for Google web search —
- Reddit: Spam policy —
- Google: Optimizing for generative AI features —



